Jump to content

trouble with super black eagle......


treedave

Recommended Posts

Here is my story..... At a family meeting about 10 years after the passing of my grandfather my grandmother wanted to do something to remember him. She decided to give each of the grand children $1,000. and let us decide what we would like to buy as a memorial to him. As he and my grandmother were both on the board of directors of the NRA and I grew up shooting with my grandfather I decided I would buy a super black eagle and have his name engraved on the reciever........ After buying it I found It was shooting low.....so i sent it back to Benelli and they told me to stack the beads (aim higher!) and it was fine. So later that year I was at a friends sporting goods store and saw the new super back eagles had a substancially higher rib in the back........ Which in turn is what i told the Benelli gunsmith I spoke with was the problem with that gun. I have tried several times to persuade customer service to exchange barrels and they tell me I have to buy another barrel through a local dealer!! That is not the kind of service I ever expected from Benelli! They told me the change was because people wanted a higher rib............UHHH!! Maybe they wanted to hit what they were aiming at. My grandmother is now 97 soon to be 98 in a few days and I am soo frustrated with Benelli I can't see spending another $425 on another barrel so I will be accepting offers from anyone who like to stack beads.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On the newer models, they also used a stainless steel recoil spring and housing, a larger trigger guard, improved the grips on the stock and forearm, and addded the ComforTech recoil reduction system.

 

Be sure and ask Benelli to replace all of those for free as well. :rolleyes:

 

The point, if it isn't already obvious to you, is that as a prior year model purchaser you are not automatically entitled to the ammendments and improvements offered in subsequent years' models.

 

It's not software. It's durable goods.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oh!!! I guess it is too much to ask for a gun that shoots where you point it........... I spend $1,200 to get a trial run that they will not stand behind???? The same year I send it back..... they change the rib design and they don't so much as offer me a discount to get a new barrel??? I am not talking about software.........this is a hardware problem. Not just a problem but a major design flaw. That they in turn rectified and give previous buyers no acknowledgement of their mistake. If I bought a car from Ford that would not stay on the road I would bet you my last dollar they would do whatever it takes to keep me on the road. I am not asking for other improvements......that is just product development. I understand things get better and evolve.......the problem I have is a design error. I have been shooting for as long as I can walk at this is the only shotgun I am unable to use......I blew the leggs off a turkey at 40 yards and the front leggs off a deer at 50 yards. Don't get me wrong.........the gun functions perfectly and has a tighter pattern than any other shotgun I have but if I can not throw it up to my shoulder and pull the trigger with confidance I will have to leave it at home!! I got this gun 7 years ago and it has been in the cabinet for the past 6 years. If anyone has a newer barrel in realtree x-tra brown let me know!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

How high do you stack the beads? 1/4" between beads is a little more than stacking..... it amounts to aiming higher. This is the only shotgun I have ever heard of that has had this problem. I have heard of other people that have also experienced this same problem and have sold them. I would not feel right selling this for anything close to what i paid for it...... that would be like doing what Benelli did to me. :( I love the feel, balance and reliability of it. I just wish I could hit something with it. If it was designed properly......how could they raise the rib in the rear by about 3/16" and not have a gun that would shoot high? Maybe I should have taken the money and bought 3 mossbergs smile.gif Every year, come hunting season I wish I could use it and instead I have to use my browning..... or my SP10.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I went to my friend's sporting goods store today and we were all talking about the SBE......and the popular opinion is that no one likes them. I am going to donate mine and start a "wall of shame". Of course I will bend the barrel in an upward direction to point out another way of correcting the misalignment of the vent rib!!!! How can you double the height of the rib in the rear and have the balls to say it was just because some customer prefered a higher rib. What about the customers that got the low rib????????????? If you change the design of a gun you should either have a recall or if you are that cheap offer a new barrel at cost!!!!! Instead of "we can put you in contact with a local distributor" And now you can have $1,625 invested in a gun that already costs more than any other comparable gun on the market. I have no problem spending the money as long as I get what I paid for and the company that made it is willing to stand behind it. Thank you Benelli for all your great customer service.......... LOL!! I am glad I never had my grandfathers name engraved on it........he would roll over in his grave. The customer service rep that I spoke to told me to have someone from the NRA call them and then they would do something......... pretty pathetic they will only help you if you have some "pull". I could ask my grandmother to make some calls... but I have no desire to own any Benelli products ever again. They do not own up to what they produce........ if you make a design error......own up to it and do the right thing. I was not looking for a new gun........just a barrel with the rib at the proper elevation. One of the guys at the sporting goods store said "why don't you put a red dot scope on it?" I did not spend $1.200 on a gun and have to mount a scope on it in order to make it hit where you are aiming. Kinda defeats the purpose of point and shoot. I am buying a Browning silver 3 1/2" smile.gif And will have it engraved in memory of my grandfather. I will also send a letter to Browing, Remington, Berreta and who ever else I find and tell them how helpful all the people at Benelli have been.... I have to sleep at night........ :eek:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Is this an SBE or SBE II?

 

In either case you could use the supplied shims to adjust the point of impact once you get your mount correct. You never mentioned that in your rants. Heck my M2 was way out in left field until I adjusted the cast and drop. Now it shoots pretty flat. But it took a fair amount of work on my part of patterning and to get a good move and mount.

 

But since you are so dead set against this gun, maybe a simpler design is what you need. :D

 

Just as a point of reference have you should check out the horror stories about Brownings service in the Browning Lovers section. :D The grass is not always greener.

 

mike smile.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Originally posted by treedave:

Of course I will bend the barrel in an upward direction to point out another way of correcting the misalignment of the vent rib!!!!

 

And now you can have $1,625 invested in a gun that already costs more than any other comparable gun on the market. I

Before you bend the barrel, I'm sure there are a number of us on here that would take your reject that you seem to not understand how to operate.

 

And by the way, there is no "any other comparable gun on the market". :rolleyes:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Mike,

I did try the shims provided.......and it never really made much of a difference. :rolleyes: I guess I have really been ranting but I can not tell you how disgusted I am with this gun and how Benelli blames it's customers inability to shoot for a defect in their design...........which has since been corrected :confused: I have lots of shotguns and I am sure I could LEARN to use the SBE but then when ever I used another shotgun I would have to retrain myself............. If they would have done SOMETHING to rectify this situation...........you all would not have to listen to my rants and raves!! I have a friend that has the newer rib design and I tried it and it was great. For me to have to spend another $425 for the new barrel is adding insult to injury.

Thank you for the FYI on Browning.......I will be sure i do alot more research before I purchase another gun. I have a Browning b-80 that I have never had a problem with . So thank god I have no dealings with their customer service. It is a great upland bird gun but it does not throw buckshot nearly as well as the Benelli :( Sometimes you do not "get what you paid for!!"

 

Not sure what would be a simpler design........every shotgun I ever picked up was "point and shoot!!"

 

Where would i find the Browning lovers section?

Thanks!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hey Husker,

 

I wish I lived in Kansas......... you guys have some monster bucks!!

I never claimed to be an expert...... but I did grow up at Cherry ridge rifle range. Probably the largest range in NJ. I played with guns while my grandfather excavated the range on an old bulldozer. He was also an Olympic referee, held numerous highpower rifle titles, served on the board of directors of the NRA fo 36 years and also was actively involved with hunter safety courses in NJ. And that is why this gun has soo much sentiment to me. I have been shooting my whole life...........and if there was not a problem with the SBE.......there would be no SBEII......whatever other improvements they made are of no concern to me......but the problem with the vent rib is a major problem :rolleyes: I have 1/2 dozen shotguns that are set up for different game and can pick any one of them up and go hunting without having to remember to stack the beads really high. I wanted this to be my buckshot gun. With a pattern master choke tube it had the tightest pattern i had ever seen :eek:

As far as the "reject"..... I stated in my first post that I was looking for offers and got none!

I honestly do not mean to sound like an a------ but the fact that Benelli knows of the problem..........changed the rib........and will do nothing for it's customers speaks for itself!! :(

 

Dave

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have owned my composite H&K SBE since 1994 and shot several thousand rounds through it. I have never noticed it not shooting where it was aimed. I did have to use the shims to adjust the drop as it was too high for me, but, since then, it is the best shooting 12 gauge I have ever owned. The barrel on your gun may be defective, but I don't think the rib placement is a design defect.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I totally agree with you..................the SBE in the pic on the link you sent is the one with the vent rib raised in the rear............The one I have has an even gap from front to rear. The one in the pic you enclosed has a much higher rib in the rear. That is the problem Benelli fixed. The higher rib height in the rear is to compensate for the screw in choke tube system that they seem to have forgotten about when they first built this gun. If the rib is not properly aligned with the bore it is gonna shoot low....!! redface.gif I have used the redesigned SBE and it is a fantastic gun........The same gun I have but with the vent rib issue corrected!! All I expect is for Benelli to stand behind the SBE and make good on it's design oversite. Maybe you guys are loaded but $1,200 is alot for me to spend on a closet ornament!!

tongue.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wouldn't have a SX2 if it was the only gun I could own.

 

I shoot the SBEII.

I have shot the earlier model SBE's and liked them just fine too.

 

Step 1 - Pattern the gun uisng a sight picture which shows a bit of rib and the beads stacked as a figure 8.

 

Step 2 - Adjust the stock using the supplied shims.

 

Step 3 - Shoot stuff!

 

loot1.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So here we go............. ;) as a last resort before bending the barrel I opted to try the shim set that would raise the heal to it's highest position and low and behold when I throw it up it actually hits what I am pointing at.......... redface.gif By doing this in effect I force myself to stack the beads resulting in a gap of about 1/4".........after shooting and double checking the sight plane. I am really kind of bewildered as to weather this is the norm...........????

Any other shotgun I ever shot was the traditional figure 8......and this seems to be a much greater gap between the beads to hit the point of aim to hit the point of impact. Which brings us back to the height of the vent rib............ If anyone has any usefull guidance I would love to be informed smile.gif

 

And Tuck........I checked with my local gunsmith and he said "The nut is fine........just a few loose screws!!" LOL

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guy's I have a smiler problem I just got my SBEII and I patterned it the other day with different buck shot off sand bags and free hand and found out while it shot a great group it was to the rt by 4" @ 25 yards and about 8 " @ 40 yards I have not played with the shims but wouldn't that just affect up and down? Any help would be much appreciated, thanks Jim

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jim,

The supplied shims adjust both cast (side to side) and drop (up and down).

Typically, a right handed gun is set up with cast off and a left handed one is cast on.

The supplied shims allow you to set yours either way, as well as cast neutral.

 

Watch epsiode 1 here.

http://americangundog.com/straightshooting_AGD1.html

 

Episode 6 here

http://americangundog.com/straightshooting_AGD2.html

 

And watch these as well.

http://www.benelliusa.com/forums/ultimatebb.php/topic/11/63.html

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...