Thanks Steve, unfortunately the finish (originial on right) is different. I spoke with Benelli and they mentioned that the tube on the left was going to be all I could find on places like Numrich, MGW, or another parts distributor. At least, unless it was already finished and taken off to be replaced by an aftermarket tube. I'm still not sure why the tube length is slightly different either. I appreciate the links though in case the customer wants to go with something like cerakote or a refinish.