Thanks to everyone for your responses. I am amazed at how many of you took time to respond. So again thanks.
Of the guns all of you have recommended I have the following list of 20ga shotguns compiled:
Benelli Nova Short Stock
Benelli Montefeltro Short Stock
870 Youth
Beretta Auto
Youth 1100 or 1187
Also recommended is looking into something like Limbsaver products, recoil reducer products, and a pad for his shoulder. I will definitely look into what was recommended by SDKIDAHO and NOBEGINNER on these products and finding a local gunsmith who could work on a nice fit for my son using these or similar products.
The pump versus automatic argument makes sense to me. I had been told that the autos kicked less than the pumps, so I was leaning that way. But I understand that learning with a pump might be better. I still am even more concerned with the kick, but this is now a new consideration. I’m really confused whether an auto or a pump kicks more. It might just depend on the make and model of the gun though.
I would pay $300 or $1500 if my son can handle the kick. So I just want the best quality, lowest kicking 20 gauge shotgun I can buy. After reading all these suggestions and reading on the manufacturers’ websites, I’m leaning toward the Nova Pump Short Stock. I just love Benelli, so I know my bias is part of that. I would buy one of the other recommended guns though if I knew it would kick less than the Nova. I wish the Nova had the Comfortech stock. I would think that would help reduce the kick. Why isn’t that part of the Nova? Also, if I knew that the Montefeltro kicked less than the Nova, I would reconsider the auto versus pump argument.
So I am still working through a ton of issues, but now leaning toward the Benelli Nova Short Stock. I appreciate everyone posting responses. I feel much more knowledgeable now than this morning. I’m looking forward to any other responses you may have.
Thanks again. Chad