The OP's premise was that the only end-user review he had seen was negative, and he wondered if that was representative or an outlier. He did so on a public, specialty, forum, thereby requesting "public" (end-user) input.
Alllso... the gun mag links you posted all carry several hundred thousand $$ in Benelli/Beretta Holdings advertising dollars. This is referred to as "inherent bias." Evaluating inherent bias is part of my profession, so I do have some valid insight, regarding the issue.
I'm new. I can also be an A88 at times, but I generally don't pick peter fights with folks having 300% more posts/input than I have. Significantly more maturity, it would also appear, in context...