I would recommend the 5 MOA SRO for a defensive shotgun. I'm an avid USPSA shooter and most guys in open and carry optics run a 5 to 6 and sometimes larger MOA dots. This is because it picks up significantly faster than a smaller dot for most people. The argument is that you can turn up a smaller dot and make it appear larger. This is true, however, for many people it's detracting because it "blooms" the dot. I personally hate this and prefer and crisp round dot that isn't glaring bright and spikey looking. Also, a 5 MOA dot is only about an inch or so at 25 yards so it's more precise than the shotgun will ever be.