OK, OK------ Tucker and mudhen,
I guess it comes down to personal preference. You made good points defending the SBE II. As far as appearance goes, I like the looks of the SBE 1 better------- and it is a proven model. For me the SBE 1 is fine because I wear "trigger finger" gloves, when I wear gloves, so I have no need for the enlarged guard.
Like the old saying goes----- "each to his own".