Jump to content

remarkable

Members
  • Posts

    464
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    30

Posts posted by remarkable

  1. On 4/7/2020 at 12:47 AM, Niedermeier23 said:

    Hello everyone, new to the forum here.

    Over the last couple of years I have began to be plagued by cycling issues regarding my SBE2, in specifics 2 3/4 inch shells. 
    Now I would like to start by saying this is a gun that I have owned for going on 11 years and have put close to 20,000 rounds through it during that time. I noticed the problem dove hunting a couple years ago when it wouldn’t fully cycle Remington Gun clubs. Since then it absolutely will not cycle any target load, and will not cycle most 2 3/4 magnum rounds. It will either stove pipe the empty hull or eject it but the next round will get caught under the bolt carrier (bolt won’t cycle all the way back). This problem has lead me to purchasing another shotgun.

    Now that that is addressed I would like to add this. I have tried several different kinds of cleaners including CLP, Lucas gun oil, frog lube, hoppes, and clenzoil. I’ve tried powdered graphite along the slide rail, I’ve tried well oiled, light oiled, and bone dry. I’ve cleaned every nook and cranny in this gun you can imagine. I have also replaced the recoil spring with a Wolff XP and have tried a RP spring, as well as a factory replacement. I’ve replaced magazine caps followers, inertia springs, and locking pin retainer. (I’m sure I’m leaving something out).

    I love the gun, I shoot it very well but I can’t trust the reliability issues. Any advice or comments would be appreciated as I would love to get the gun back shooting again so I don’t have to keep shooting a dang beretta 

    This sound like a Carrier that is out of adjustment.  A few issues have come up in this thread that requires careful thought. Benelli guns that are sent to Benelli USA are not sent to Italy for repair.  When replacing Super Black Eagle recoil spring my choice is generally the OEM Benelli spring that can get purchased at Midwest Gun Works part number 61088. The Wolff 25% increase spring is to stiff for "Light Loads" remembering the minimum oz. for 3.5" Benelli is 1 1/8. Many guns will shoot lighter in the right environment such as correct shouldering, warmer weather, shooting from the 11 O'clock to the 1 O'clock when the bolt now faces the force of gravity.   I am including a list of Quick Tips that I have shared several times.  The list general in applications list good insights on Cycling and Benelli fitting.   

    QUICK TIPS – Benelli

     

    Ø SHOOTING BB’S – EVERY SHELL MUST DROP FREELY INTO CHAMBER – MOST DON’T, BENELLI BORES GUN TIGHT – CAPTURE ENERTIA

    Ø ENERTIA GUNS MUST BE SHOULDERD

    Ø CORRECT RECOIL SPRING –

    Ø RECOIL SPRING TOLERANCES EVEN NEW ARE POOR

    Ø CLEAN GUN

    Ø RECOIL SPRING TUBE – CLEAN VERY LITTLE LUBE

    Ø IF THE MAGAZINE IS NOT RELEASING SHELLS OR RELEASES MULTIPLES YOUR CARRIER LATCH OR DROP SHELL LEVER IS OUT OF SPEC, MAYBE BOTH

    Ø SHOOTING OVERHEAD 10 OCLOCK TO 2 OCLOCK WILL TEST MOST BENELLI’S RECOIL SPRING  AND CLEANING – BOLT NOW HAS TO FACE THE FORCE OF GRAVITY RETURNING TO 1/16 TWIST BATTERY

    Ø MOST GUNS THAT SHOOT HIGH ARE NOT FITTED PROPERLY – FLAT RIB, FLOAT TARGET

    Ø MOST GUNS THAT SHOOT LEFT OR RIGHT, IS AN EYE ALIGNMENT FITTING ISSUE

    Ø BENELLI PATTERNING SPEC IS:

     

    Benelli Pattern Spec:

    Up to 2” right of left

    Up to 5” above POA

    Up to 2” Below POA

    At 21 yards

    Please reach out if I can further assist.

  2. The M2 has a rear spring that IMO is a bit soft, secondly as noted recoil spring tolerances,  vary from gun to gun, wish they were better.  With that I replace M2 recoil springs in most cases with a Wolff OEM power spring, and have had improved performance and less tolerance variation from spring to spring.  

    Your photo which is nice does not provide details such as: is this a new shell going forward or the old shell not ejecting.

    Underestimating the importance of shouldering a inertia recoil gun is quite often a difficult conversation with gun owners, it in many cases evokes a responses that discounts, minimizes and deflects its importance in core cycling issues.

    Please let me know if I can help.

    • Like 1
  3. You provided very little detail such as how old the gun is, ammo choice, shouldering, etc.. Here is a list of quick tips that I have together - experience level; Expert

    image.thumb.png.6260a2d8146ea596ec9a39fe3d2701c2.png

  4. 23 minutes ago, Beco said:

    I purchased a Benelli Ethos 12 gauge shotgun and after a couple of years I had an issue trying to disassemble the shotgun.    The tube would not disengage and I had to pry it apart with a screwdriver.   It was sent to Benelli and they stated it was due to misuse.   If that was the issue I would have never been able to assembly it before I started my dove hunt.   Even though they say that they offer a 10 year warranty, this was not covered by Benelli,  it's sad that you spend thousands on a shotgun and now I have to spend money to buy another barrel.

    I will never purchase another Benelli and I will not recommend Benelli to anyone else.

    "The tube would not disengage and I had to pry it apart with a screwdriver".   Could you explain this further.  It would be very helpful to look up the gun on the Midwest Gun Works website , go to gun parts, select Ethos then look up the actual parts name.  What is currently wrong with the gun after it was sent back to Benelli, did they repair, maybe someone can assist you to correct the core of your issue.

    Please PM me if so desired.

  5. Benelli # 80155 has the correct parts to effectively deliver and store shells in the magazine tube with damaging the Carrier Latch when shells are released from the magazine tube.

    Guns that release multiple shells from the magazine have in most cases bent Carrier Latches or out of spec drop shells levers, or both.

    Please let me know how I can help.

    • Like 2
  6. To correct this you will need to change your Drop Shim Plate in the rear of the gun and the corresponding drip shim.  Your gun is currently set up with the BDX Drop Shim Plate and the B Drop Shim (behind the receiver).  You could try the C DX Drop Shim Plate and the C Drop Shim, this should get you closer to looking flat down the rib.  You may have to move to the D DX Drop Shim Plate and D Drop Shim if needed.  

     

    I have found some shooters with 26" barrels moving to the D Drop Shim Plate while 28" barrels seem to end up with the C Drop Shim Plate.  I personally own a Performance shop 24" and fitting quite nicely in the C DX Drop Shim Plate, C Drop Shim, DX 6MM.

     

    Please let me know if you may need assistance.

  7. The Benelli 828U 26" has a "High Rib" installed.  For reference the Ethos Field has a mid Rib, the Montefeltro has a Low Rib.  If you are have fitting issues, (most 828U's do not fit - out of the box) I could surely assist in walking you through the Quardra Fit System.  This is system is the most robust system of all of the Benelli models. Most 828U's out of the box will aim high. I am attaching fitting diagrams and Benelli Patterning Specs.

    image.png.0440ee11127b48ffe5cfa53b6da0e57f.png

    image.png.ac80e467e7ddc5e98315a40e40d1745c.png

    image.png.200feba5da222343035cf876624105c3.png

  8. Here are some Quick Tips that I have put together after working on over 1100 Benelli's, 100% "Cycles Shells Like New". Another way to word this, both of your guns   would be 100% as well.  Please let me know how I can help.

    QUICK TIPS – Benelli

     

    Ø SHOOTING BB’S – EVERY SHELL MUST DROP FREELY INTO CHAMBER – MOST DON’T, BENELLI BORES GUN TIGHT – CAPTURE ENERTIA

    Ø ENERTIA GUNS MUST BE SHOULDERD

    Ø CORRECT RECOIL SPRING –

    Ø RECOIL SPRING TOLERANCES EVEN NEW ARE POOR

    Ø CLEAN GUN

    Ø RECOIL SPRING TUBE – CLEAN VERY LITTLE LUBE

    Ø IF THE MAGAZINE IS NOT RELEASING SHELLS OR RELEASES MULTIPLES YOUR CARRIER LATCH OR DROP SHELL LEVER IS OUT OF SPEC, MAYBE BOTH

    Ø SHOOTING OVERHEAD 10 OCLOCK TO 2 OCLOCK WILL TEST MOST BENELLI’S RECOIL SPRING  AND CLEANING – BOLT NOW HAS TO FACE THE FORCE OF GRAVITY RETURNING TO 1/16 TWIST BATTERY

    Ø MOST GUNS THAT SHOOT HIGH ARE NOT FITTED PROPERLY – FLAT RIB, FLOAT TARGET

    Ø MOST GUNS THAT SHOOT LEFT OR RIGHT, IS AN EYE ALIGNMENT FITTING ISSUE

    Ø BENELLI PATTERNING SPEC IS:

     

    Benelli Pattern Spec:

    Up to 2” right of left

    Up to 5” above POA

    Up to 2” Below POA

    At 21 yards

     

  9. Howie

    Quadrafit - Benelli fitting system, in the M2 is not as robust as the 828U where you have 3mm & 6mm of cast right or left.  You could try to purchase a new drop shim plate however I believe you are going to run into difficulties fitting the OEM SX drop shim.  In shotgun fitting there is another method which basically is "fitting the shooter to the gun"... in short you are correctly positioning the gun, drop & cast before you shoulder the gun.

     

     

  10. image.png.426b9cbf025842e695f6a28d5eb45dbb.png

    The Benelli Pattern spec as noted, your gun is shooting left more than likely because your eye is not aligned down the barrel, if you eye right eye is to far to the right, you will "CORRECT" this by moving the stock of the gun to the right - you are now pointing the gun to the left.  Remembering you are shooting the gun... to correct this you could cast your gun left handed and use the DSX Drop Shim Plate and the corresponding SX Cast Shim and the D Drop Shim.  I have set up many right handed shooters with this setup with very good results.   Please let me know how I can help.

     

  11. Spoke to Rob Roberts today, both 12 & 20  gauge Performance Shop Waterfowl SBE 3 & M2 - honed and polished action, custom-tuned trigger group, ended after the 2019 build guns.  

    I personally own a SBE PS 3 which was patterned by Rob Roberts - pattern included with every gun.  The center of the pattern was Center slightly low of POA, with 1/2".  Most "Shooting High" issues are caused by improper fitting, you must have the barrel flat.  Remembering you are shooting the gun... Benelli fitting system is very effective to bring most shooters into above said position - Flat Rib!  I have found several shooters benefit from casting the gun left handed/right hand shooter to get proper eye alignment, side to side.

    It is critical to note Benelli Pattern Specs - no one talks about this critical metric.

    CENTER OF PATTER MAY BE:

    Up to 2" left or right of Point of Aim

    Up to 5" above Point Of Aim 

    Up to 2" below Point Of Aim

    AT 21 YARDS

    Most SBE 3's WHEN FITTED PROPERLY will shot with the delta 1-3 inches high at 21 yards, this establishes a great 60/40 pattern.  

    • Upvote 1
  12. 9 hours ago, steiger68 said:

     # 10357, OPTIFADE™ Marsh Benelli shotguns are already recognized as the greatest semiautomatics on the market. With Benelli’s Performance Shop enhancements, the ultimate waterfowl scatter guns just got better. Custom work and features include: honed and polished action, custom-tuned trigger group, three Rob Roberts Triple Threat® choke tubes, lengthened and polished forcing cone, HIVIZ® CompSight®, oversized bolt handle, enlarged bolt release and a paracord survival sling. Waterfowl Edition models are testfired with a computerized pattern analysis machine to ensure consistent and even patterns

    no response from Rob Roberts I sent them an email … 

    This description was posted in the 2019 Dealer Workbook, I see different description of the PS Waterfowl Model, after 2019.  Will be interesting to find out.

     

     

  13. There is no mention of "tuned trigger group or the honed and polished bolt," after 2019 Benelli Dealer Workbook.  I will be contact Rob Roberts this week on other topics as well.  This is on both 12 & 20 gauge models.  Will update after contact.

     

    • Upvote 1
  14. The gun is designed to shoot a 60/40 pattern, this pellet count should be taken from the 21 yard line - a 6" circle is placed above the point of aim - the pellet count ideally will be 60 % high of the middle of the 6" circle.

    Guns shooting higher are guns that typically do not fit the shooter, and can be adjusted with the Benelli fitting system.

    Remembering you are shooting the gun.

  15. 4 hours ago, k7sullivan said:

    Just curious, did you ever get a definitive solution on this? 

     

    I also have the same issue, I've had my sbe 2 for 15 years and have fired 1000's of heavy waterfowl rounds through it. My cartridge drop lever gets stuck up and I need to stick my finger in the bottom of the carrier and press the carrier latch back in, it locks closed and the I can continue to cycle shells. I've changed every spring on the gun, and the issue persists. 

     

    At this point I plan on purchasing a new trigger assembly, but if someone has a better idea, I would be all ears. 

     

    Thanks for the help 

    Please PM me, it sound like your carrier latch is not in alignment with the drop shells lever.  Having worked on over 1050 Benelli the repair is not extensive, buying a new trigger pack is not needed.

  16. The Performance Center Super Sport was sent to Briley for Briley Parts as well as force coning work, back boring, trigger and action polishing.   Without seeing the gun my hunch is the disconnector and possibly the trigger shoe is now out of spec.  Please reach out if you would like additional insights on how to test the disconnector.

     

     image.png.1f51104113c085296743291911864163.png

    • Upvote 1
×
×
  • Create New...