I assume the extension you bought was stripped?
You have two options, you can buy the flexible ring to install or you can modify your old receiver extension to get the flexible ring out. Do you have a Dremel with a cut off disc to notch the raceway?
I guess you have a third option, you can send me the extension and I’d get it out for you, and install it in the new extension if you want. Just cover the cost of return shipping.
Buy option:
https://www.midwestgunworks.com/page/mgwi/prod/70071